
Astro-Seek.com Seek and meet people born on the same date as you ...
About sidereal and tropical system - Discussions, questions
About sidereal and tropical system
June 23, 2020 at 20:59 (UT/GMT)

About sidereal and tropical system
I was curious about which one is more accurate ? I know it may sound strange as both of them are used frequently.But i mean my natal chart totally changes like signs of planets houses etc.Which one should i pay more attention as they reveal totally different results ?

Posts in topic
June 23, 2020 at 23:05

It´s more accurate, I know not everyone feels that way, and I´m not here to convert, but you asked, so ;)
I´d say, study both charts and see which one fits you / your life more to a T.
But, start with sidereal first

More accurate predictions are made with sidereal
a quick example but in sidereal your ascendant is Leo ..just from your profile pic alone screams LEO to me.

June 24, 2020 at 10:49

Its just looks nonsense to me as charts are totally different like describes two totally different personalities.Anyway tnx for suggestion


June 26, 2020 at 07:01

=====
Sidereal is generally hailed as more accurate concerning predicative astrology. For natal or psychological astrology, Tropical seems to utilize a more individuated approach to a native´s chart.
I think both, used in conjunction, can produce a really well rounded picture of the native and events surrounding their energetic "sphere of influence", so to speak.
A lot of people struggle with identifying with their sidereal chart (especially as like you said it can be quite different) but the difference between both mathematically is anywhere from 21~ - 24~ degrees, meaning there isn´t a ton of change relative to the overall "pattern" of the chart. Even aspects can be largely the same, as well as houses.
I work with both, and admittedly there isn´t a lot of push for sidereal astrology outside of Vedic. I´m hoping this will change as its predictive measures are great!
But long story short, IMHO they are both accurate, just used for different things.



June 26, 2020 at 13:02

=====
If it sounds like nonsense....it´s because it probably is nonsense. And if you are afraid of triggering anyone by saying it.....just place the onus of proof on them. That´ll teach them a lesson :P

June 27, 2020 at 18:29

Just probabilities.So i dont like using that word much when im talking about astrology.But what can i see,that its differs form on to other.Some people may agree for them sidereal is pretty accurate while others will say its bullshit the one and only accurate system is western. :)


June 27, 2020 at 22:42

=====
"More accurate predictions are made with sidereal"
Care to prove your wild claim, as I know many who do a good job with either system?
Funny how your profile chart is listed with the Placidus house system; no lunar mansions?
Maybe you should read up on the subject a little more, as a morally guided professional would not make such wild claims.
I think you should concentrate on your own 7th house moon in opposition to Mars (conflict), Neptune (illusion) & Uranus (stubborn independence) before proceeding with such claims?

June 28, 2020 at 03:05

Someone is having serious difficulties grasping this concept.


June 28, 2020 at 03:55

=====
right, in the name of morals, he hypocritically attacks someone elses personal chart like a playground bully looking for a fight.

June 28, 2020 at 03:58

;)


June 28, 2020 at 17:35

=====
Since you all want to copy/paste what you hear instead of researching to learn the knowledge, I’m out, never to return so give yourselves a well earned pat on the back. I do not attack people by their chart, unless that person gives morally inept opinion with research/knowledge. Carry on playing among yourselves, I will stick to real astrology!

June 28, 2020 at 17:39

June 29, 2020 at 08:03

The way I interpret it now is they are both useful. I see tropical as the temperature a person puts off, how they seem when you meet them in person, up-close. Whereas sidereal is their true essence, i.e. the actions they take, what they gravitate towards, and how they appear to be from a distance, observably.
Basically: (Tropical=More Subjective) (Sidereal=More Objective)
Although I do find sidereal ascendants to be a much clearer match, look up your moon nakshatra as well and see how that fits!

Login
Register »
© 2022 Astro-Seek.com
Sun |
Moon |
Synastry Chart |
Transit Chart |
Dominant Planet |
Name Numerology |
Life Path |
Chinese Horoscope |
Celtic Sign |
Composite |
Vedic |
VOC Moon |
Beginner's Guide |
Venus Cycle |
Sidereal Vedic Chart | Nakshatra Calculator | Best Fertility Days Calculator | Solar Return | Rectification | Full Moon July, August | Astro Calendar | Ephemeris | Astrotwins | Name Calculator | Weather Forecasting |
Midpoint Calculator | House Systems | Solar Arc | Zodiac Symbols | Zodiac Signs Dates | Mercury Retrograde | Venus | Electional | Eclipses | Gardening | Sabian Symbols | Big Three |
Daily Love Horoscope | Tarot Astrology | Planetary Overview | Chart Interpretations | Natal Aspects | Synastry Aspects | Transit Aspects | Fixed Stars | Sinastria | Carta Natal | Horóscopos gratuitos |
Sidereal Vedic Chart | Nakshatra Calculator | Best Fertility Days Calculator | Solar Return | Rectification | Full Moon July, August | Astro Calendar | Ephemeris | Astrotwins | Name Calculator | Weather Forecasting |
Midpoint Calculator | House Systems | Solar Arc | Zodiac Symbols | Zodiac Signs Dates | Mercury Retrograde | Venus | Electional | Eclipses | Gardening | Sabian Symbols | Big Three |
Daily Love Horoscope | Tarot Astrology | Planetary Overview | Chart Interpretations | Natal Aspects | Synastry Aspects | Transit Aspects | Fixed Stars | Sinastria | Carta Natal | Horóscopos gratuitos |