Contradictions in birth chart - Discussions, questions

Rosincvist .........Your chart is better than average.........stop imagining that it is some wicked grimoire! The key comet is noteworthy!

astrolougy » Rosincvist Oh! Why is that noteworthy?
And what makes a chart better or worse?

Dilanakia Your chart is like a minimalistic danish design compare to mine!

I think your chart indicates a good health very prominently.
Anyways I also have contradictions and I was talking with a super experienced astrolog. He told me for example in my 8 th house Venus is more prominent. I have both Mars and Venus in 8 th and they create contradictions. Not ignoring Mars but still venus take let’s say 80 percent of it. Then I still need work on Mars issues there. So the Venus becomes more dominant if that makes sense.

So I am not sure from where you saw chronic problems but check which aspect or sign is more dominant. Is a planet in it s own ruler sign , is the planet exalted in that sign etc.

(dragonfly) Hi :-)

You need to find more indicators before you can say, that your chart clearly shows tendency for example towards chronic diseases or the other way around, towards excellent health. As far as I know a strong Sun indicates a good health, and I guess the ruler of the 6th house should be in good dignity and well aspected.

I think all charts contain some contradictions. Sometimes you can find mutually exclusive information in birth charts, which are manifested in the personality. For example a birth chart shows that someone is both lazy and hard-working or dominat and aggressive as well as charming and kind. That doesn´t to have be a missinterpretation. You can be very hard-working, but there comes a time in your life, when you don´t care so much about work and you start directing your attention elsewhere. You can also be polite most of the time, but also very dominat in some situations. The human nature is full of contradictions, and no wonder you can see these reflected in birth charts.

Cind I think your chart looks okay. Monitor transits or progressed chart.

My 6th house stellium is shocking. My gut issues were so bad before I went vegan, it is a lot better now.

I have a lot of allergies as well and when I was little I had to go to a centre as I was always ill.

I think if there is nothing major going on in your life I wouldn´t really pay attention to the placement description you find online. Look at your specific chart, the ruler of houses and how they are aspected.

Cecilia_3 Health issues may arise after some transits trigger your planets. According to your chart, I saw some fixed stars that cause some health issues like sport accidents, gas poisoning, asthma, eye problems, like venusian hair loss problems etc.

Sag_Stellium "One placements says my health is excellent, and the other means I´ve got chronic health issues."
Do you currently have health issues? or are you worried that what some interpretations say about health issues might (God Forbid) be true?

In case of contradictions in a chart, I usually give more weight to the aspect having the outer-most planet, since that is said to be the more influencial one in most aspects (in Tropical atleast).

Maybe you could mention the placements you saw the interpretations of? That might help clarify things a bit.

(dragonfly) » Jaided "I think it´s smart to pay attention to 6th house transits."

You are right. Transiting Neptune through the sixth house can manifest itself in health problems that are not easy to diagnose.

JayJayAstrology Everyone has some contradictions in their chart, but not of the kind you suggest. Who says your chart shows good health and then chronic health? I question both interpretations. We really cannot tell the health of a person just like that - not really. Even if they have all the markers of a certain disease - we can not tell if it will manifest. So, I would not take either interpretation seriously.

_______________________________________________________________

My website: http://thesoulmustsing.weebly.com - I do western astrology readings, dream interpretation, and mind-body healing by a donation of your choice - and classes at reasonable rates. Sign up for my newsletter!

(dragonfly) » Jaided The more I dig into the subject of Neptune, the more I feel that its malefic nature is underestimated. I am currently experiencing Neptune transiting through my 6th house. Unfortunately, I can´t say anything good about it. When I read that Neptune is foggy and its transit can make it difficult to properly assess a situation, I think that reflects my experience perfectly. In my case, some health questions have arisen that remain unanswered so far. But reading your post I just realized that before Neptune leaves my 6th house, it will be joined by Saturn.

astrolougy » Sag_Stellium Hey! I just checked my notes and by Saturn in the 8th house I wrote down chronic health issues, and yes I do have some, but I don´t feel sick all the time, so maybe that´s why I´ve also read about an excellent health. Unfortunateley I can´t find thas placement anymore...