Ok let s settle the Placidus/whole Sign debate - Discussions, questions

rohini moon Who´s the stud?

Emanuel https://patrickwatsonastrology.com/…

https://patrickwatsonastrology.com/…

https://www.youtube.com/watch/…

https://www.youtube.com/watch/…

https://www.youtube.com/watch/…

https://www.youtube.com/watch/…

PErsonal Note : I like the idea that planets in a sign are all in the same house ( as in Whole Sign a Sign coresponds to a house) . In have Venus,Uranus,Mars and Jupiter in Aquarius. In placidus Venus and Uranus are in 8th house, Jupiter and Mars in 9th house . I feel this interpretation of placements in houses dissipate the "work together" energy that planets in the same sign . All planets in a sign work together in a way or another ( not actual conjunctions by degree,but conjunction be signs) ....and it feel off that their energy dissipate in different houses. For me it make sense that the energy of planets in the same sign (usually stelliums) are used just in one house .

Emanuel » astreo It´s funny cuz as I said,I was a big hater of whole sign (for not very valid reasons ). The core reason was that i didnt like many things astrologer Patrick Watson said ... I thought it was too fckin pretentious . So I just "hate" it . The other reason was MArs and Jupiter are in 9th house in Placidus,and I read somewhere that Mars and Jupiter make someone a very preachy individual,passionate anbout religious and academic matters ,very lucky in academic matter etc. Things usually related to 9th house and Jupiter/Sagittarius (though the core signification of 9th house didnt came from Sagittarius ) etc. I liked the idea of Jupiter being in 9th house (it s "domicile" in Alphabet letter system) and be somewhat "blessed" because of it . And I used much confirmation bias for this lol.

But i start to think....hmmm maybe my interest in religion,politics,other countries and their culture is not because I have Jupiter in 9th house ,but because i fckin have a Sagittarius Mercury in sextile with my aquarius Jupiter . I was another person from that point lmao.

astreo Better explain your mismatches with Whole Sign / Placidus.
It would be interesting to read it.

astreo